I realise there’s much that Delhiites (or anyone, for that
matter) could find to disagree with in this post. Therefore, I qualify this by
stating that this is purely based on what I’ve seen so far in the few parts of the
city I’ve had a chance to be around, and the few people I’ve had a chance to
observe – which I’ll admit is really not much at all. So excuse the seeming generalisations,
because I’m telling myself there’s a lot more to Delhi that I have yet to see,
know and understand. But then again, can you truly understand any city, can you
truly shed the circumstances you were born in and are in?
Anyway, the one thing that perturbs me most is how there is
a clear line of hierarchy for nearly everything. I will qualify this again by
saying that this is true of the rest of the country too – and perhaps the rest
of the world as well. But nowhere in my few travels and the three cities I’ve
lived in have I seen it play out as obviously as it is done in Delhi. Every interaction
seems tinged with a sense of ‘you better know who you’re dealing with…’ - and I'm not even talking about workplace hierarchical levels. One
friend said that Delhi has a strong ‘naukar chakkar,’ and I can’t help but
agree. Coming from a middle-class family from Chennai, I’m unable to comprehend
the extent to which people rely on – what do I call them, servants? – their maids,
cooks, drivers and other kinds of helpers for so many things. I see the idea
that because we pay them, we are entitled to much. Help we demand – we hardly
request – ranges from bringing up our bags from the car, to bringing a spoon
from the kitchen, to clearing our hair off the bathroom floor, to cutting our
apple, to plugging our laptop charger in the socket a tad unreachable, under
the table. I see that we are annoyed when someone refuses to do anything we ask,
because, heck, we deserve it because we pay
them so much. I see that we are always suspicious about the very people who
help us get by everyday, because if you’re
too nice you’re going to be ripped off someday or you’ll be taken advantage of.
I see this attitude translating into how we talk to them – there’s a customary bhaiyya or didi attached to every sentence, but it doesn’t mask the tone of
you-better-do-what-I-say. Someone living in my house compound had the audacity
to tell construction workers who live in the half-built apartment they are
constructing behind my place, and cooking on random fuel they’ve collected,
that they don’t cook meat there because the badboo
is coming into his house courtyard. The security guard of the hotel nearby
proudly yells at the rickshaw-drivers to get out of the entrance to the hotel. The
big car honks the brains out of the smaller car and forget how everyone treats pedestrians.
I’m deeply annoyed myself that I’ve employed a cook, and
even as I try to justify it by saying that the kinds of conveniences available
to me in Singapore – of readily-available, inexpensive food steps outside my
office and in umpteen malls and food courts paces outside my home – I feel
angry that I’ve also become reliant on someone for a basic need. I’ve been told
that I should yell at her when required, for she won’t take me seriously
otherwise.
It’s seriously disturbing. I know I’ve not had a chance to
see much of Chennai because I never went to college or worked there, but I honestly
doubt that most people from a background similar to mine from Chennai would be
able to relate to this. Of course, all of our houses employ women who come to
clean the house and do the dishes, and I’m sure there are people who behave in
different ways with their helpers, but somehow, this attitude is scary. Singapore is also full of domestic
maids who immigrate from other southeast Asian nations, and I have heard horror
stories of how some of them are treated – as many as I’ve heard of maids who
have truly become family. I haven’t, however, seen this overt class distinction
play out there at least among the Singaporeans. The average Singaporean, to my
knowledge, is respectful – or at least tolerant – of the people who clean her
toilets, cook her food, and sweep the roads. The city taught me to be
self-reliant, clean bathrooms, pick hair off the drain, and do my dishes on my
own – so much so that my mother, who has often ranted about the hair I leave
behind whenever I wash it, was surprised that I started clearing it once I moved
to my own house in Singapore. Of course, I acknowledge the massive difference in
backgrounds, situations and cultures here, and realise that most people I'm talking about, in Delhi, in India, have never had to be in a situation where hiring domestic help is a costly
affair.
I’m not judging people for behaving in a particular manner,
trying to portray that we treat people better in the South or pretending to be
a superior person, etc. – I will not fall into that simplistic trap of painting
people with the same brush, or of assuming false morality in my behaviour. I’m simply registering something that surprises me.
This is something that I’m taking time to get used to, and maybe months down
the line it won’t bother me at all. And, how do I put this without making it
sound like I’m judging? I hope that come what may, I don’t change how I behave
with people.