War and death

, , 24 comments
I doubt if I have transferred all the seriousness, irritation and desperation that I had when writing this post; maybe it’s good if it hasn’t.

For the past four weeks, almost ever since school started again, I’ve been reading only these in a particular subject: genocides, terrorism and war. Death, death and more death. It leaves me stunned, stumped for words.

We watched gory videos of The Holocaust that happened during WWII. I watched, in utter horror, as Hitler went about killing millions of people, and how thousands of human beings helped him kill others. I read about the Armenian genocide in the Ottoman Empire, about Stalin’s artificially created famine which killed millions again, and the Cambodian Khmer Rouge genocide. My mind is sick with the details, and I’m stuck wondering at the futility of the intelligence, the sixth sense that God (or Nature, if you wish) has specially endowed to the human kind.

I’m horrified as the details about how people were exterminated are laid down in detail for us to study. What is the point studying it if we never learn? If we never resolve not to repeat the terrible, unforgivable mistakes? Well, such large-scale extermination as The Holocaust or the Khmer Rouge hasn’t happened in the recent past as we know it, but I’m sure some silent killing is going on everywhere, probably right in our country too.

Who are we to decide certain people don't deserve the right to live? Who are we to take upon ourselves, the responsibility to apparently ‘cleanse’ the world of such ‘scum’? We haven’t learnt. I don’t know if we ever will.

And what disturbs me most is the fact that for all that I ramble, for all that understanding we have that this is wrong, we hardly choose to do anything about it. What, I wonder, have I done in my capacity to even try to rid the world of all this. Sadly, I draw a blank. Nothing. I wonder again, if I will ever be able to do anything to help matters. Can we ever do anything?

As a survivor of The Holocaust aptly put it (lifted straight from my lecture notes), “When I heard about Cambodia, I went into a depression, because the world had not learned. I felt guilty that I’m living in a beautiful home with all the comforts—and I am impotent. I do nothing. It pains me, terribly, that the world has not learned that you don’t kill your brother or sister, no matter what the reasons. I share the guilt today. I do.”

Sharing the guilt - is that all we can do?

24 comments:

யாத்ரீகன் said...

War isnt the only place/time where these things happen, even the bloodshed during a caste riot is also the same kind....

we need not share the guilt, instead we could do our part in the society by spreading love and thoughts among the people we face in our day to day life, our family and our friends, thoughts those are against caste,language and any differences causing such hatred...

every long journey starts with a small step, so never mind taking a small step !

Sandhya Ramachandran said...

A very heartfelt writing... I do not know why people fight, hate each other, kill, commit crimes. Dunno why people are sometimes possessed with such an abnormal feeling of mounting rage,that they chose to stoop down to kill theri own brethren. As you said, we can do nothing but cry along or just resolve not to stoop so low and feed on the filth ourselves!

"Life is too short to despise people who simply can't help what they've done"

Don't let the past haunt you. Let's just make sure our progeny doesn't witness such gory crimes!

Kausikram Krishnasayee said...

they died because they killed. retaliation kills more than aggression. life is not a fairy tale and it will never be one. there are only two classes of people in this world, those who are born to kill and those who are born to die.

Asha said...

Normally, when I see/read such in papers/tv... what I'd do is, ignore them. Yes, I'm ignorant. Unfeeling? I don't know... it just gets to me so I try not to let it get to me.

That's how it is. Such is the world. Some things we don't have the ability to change.

Somehow things happen, and they happen for some reason, good or bad.

Anonymous said...

tutsi genocide in rwanada, the balkan conflict,

Anonymous said...

Every single day we are being bombarded with stories of killings in the Africas or some massacre that took place in the remote hills of cambodia, so much so that we have become desensitised to such occurences. If the holocaust probably took place in recent times, i am afraid most of us won't even bat an eyelid. As heartless and cruel it may seem, the plain and simple truth is we simply don't care anymore. After all to us, it's just another story on the daily news. I believe Josef Stalin said it best when he infamously quoted “A single death is a tragedy, a million deaths is a statistic.”

genocides have never gone out of fashion. The tutsi genocide in rwanda, the prosecution of the maynard people in vietnam or the karen people in myanmar or the tibetans in china, the balkan conflict and the list continues on. As u remarked, it is the sixth sense that god has gifted to humans which makes us commit such atrocities. After all how many of us have heard of animals being involved in genocides.

Anyway to sum up this extra long remark, i leave you with this few lines from one my fav songs by John Lennon. And remember, an eye for an eye would leave the world blind.

"You may say I'm a dreamer
But I'm not the only one
I hope someday you'll join us
And the world will be as one"


(p.s. sorry about the earlier mis-written remark. Hope u can remove it.... *grin*)

TamilPonnu said...

oomph thats a depressing subj.

Anonymous said...

"What, I wonder, have I done in my capacity to even try to rid the world of all this. Sadly, I draw a blank. Nothing. I wonder again, if I will ever be able to do anything to help matters. Can we ever do anything?"


Learn!!!There is no better teacher than life...

My view on life changed completely after watching the movies and reading articles based on world war II...

These genocides have brought into light many great heros like schlinder, Paul Rusesabagina's (Hotel Rwanda) etc..

We pray for peace but at the same time when pushed into such a situation should take a lesson from the war heros..

Karthik

Sheks said...

an emotional post!surprising!

violence and bloodshed still exist in this world bcos we the people havent taken enough initiatives to curb them.unless we set aside our materialistic desires,the world will never be peaceful.

Ramya Shankar said...

Ulagile shanti nilava vendum...

Vani Viswanathan said...

Yathrigan,
No, it's hardly during the war...mostly these happen silently when the war is going, when people pay more attention to the war bloodshed than to these...
And hardly are these genocides caused by a whole group of people; i mean there's usually one person who manages to incite a whole group into violence....
So we should hope, as most of us don't have any such tendencies, someday things should improve!

Sheks said...

yathirigan reminds me of central station for "yathirigan kripaya dhyaan de.."

Anonymous said...

//We pray for peace but at the same time when pushed into such a situation should take a lesson from the war heros

Heroes are just ordinary people like you and me who when the situation called for it stood up and took action. After all it's the easiest thing to keep quiet when presented with an atrocity. But it takes courage to stand up against it. "Courage is not the lack of fear; it is rather the capacity to move ahead in spite of fear".


//unless we set aside our materialistic desires,the world will never be peaceful.

Now that's what i call wishful thinking. Which man can set aside materialistic desires. It would be hypocritical to suggest such. After all who among us does not desire a better life or the means to buy the objects of our desire. If the only way for the world to schieve peace is for us all to live as a "sadhu", i believe it is an impossible notion.

Vani Viswanathan said...

Sandhya,
>>"Life is too short to despise people who simply can't help what they've done"
A beautiful line; nevertheless, seems like letting people get away for things they have done!

>>Don't let the past haunt you. Let's just make sure our progeny doesn't witness such gory crimes!
Definitely. And what do we do for that?

Vani Viswanathan said...

mark isuak,
Oh, isn't that just like giving up? Life doesn't have to be a fairy tale, but that doesn't mean we have the right to deny life to some people, or watch this act of denial going on!!

thewoman,
Again, does that mean we're not in control of our destiny (or fate)?

tamilponnu,
you bet! :(

Vani Viswanathan said...

Karthik,
True..those were some brilliant movies. But how many of us dare to be an Oscar Shindler? Or are allowed to do so? (I mean, someway or the other, someone down the line would persuade you to 'just leave it alone, you can't change things')
Whatever said, though, one thing we can do is to learn. And have we learnt at least in the recent past? I live with hope.

Sheks,
C'mon on, man....how many of your materialistic possessions will you be willing to give up? That's a-near-impossible thought. At this point of time, when so many luxuries are becoming neccessities, it's too wishful to think that by giving up materialism, we can get peace. We should only come up with new solutions, GIVEN the situation we are in right now; expecting society to give up its materialism is going too hopeful!

Dante,
Thanks for your comments. I got to rush now, so I'll read your last comment properly soon! :)

Asha said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Asha said...

*scratches head* Don't ask me difficult questions to answer can? I'm such a dumbass when it comes to topics like this. :( I knew I should've kept my fingers to myself.

~phobiac~ said...

what can I say...U've said it all....

Vani Viswanathan said...

Ramya,
Oh, kandippa venum!!!

thewoman,
oh..it's ok, lor ;)

phobiac,
Have I? *scratching chin* Where? I've only posed questions as long as I can remember!

Vani Viswanathan said...

Dante,
Are you really sure we won't 'bat an eyelid' if the Holocaust were to happen today? If that's the state of affairs today, I must confess I'm ashamed to live in such a world!! Though I can't help agreeing: I'm not sure if you know, but there was a stampede in Chennai during relief distribution...and all we had were two political parties blaming each other, while people who actually cared about the deaths, silently went about and lit candles in memory of the dead.
And just remembered, I have to study the Rwandan genocide next!

Anonymous said...

“All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing.” Doesn't this quote says it best ....

(p.s. hope u dun mind me asking but juz curious why is it tat u hate guys with moustaches ??? *grin*)

Shriedhar said...

all is fair in love n war ;)

Vani Viswanathan said...

Dante,
Who said I hate guys with moustaches? It's just that most of the guys I've liked don't have moustaches!! (yeah, with the exception of Arvind Swamy ;))
>>>*grins*
Boy, you do grin a LOT!!! :D
*grins* :P

Shreedhar,
Awwww....thathuvams!!!!